I just received a letter this week from GI asking for $1750 for two images on our webpage (the web designer made the page 9 years ago and denies any knowledge). I am planning to offer a settlement amount. If they do not take that, and they probably won't, I am inclined to pay in full rather than have a collection agency after me. Then file a small claims suit asking for the $1750. Small claims is a court of equity and a favorable judgement is a possibility. They also have to show up or forfeit. Has anyone sued them back or threatened to do so?