ExtortionLetterInfo Forums
Retired Forums => Legal Controversies Forum => Topic started by: Nodge on July 15, 2014, 01:17:55 PM
-
I was wondering if I took a still from a movie and hand painted it in oil on canvas say, would I be able to sell it or would copyright law forbid it? What about if I took the still image and ran it through some graphics software which made it look as though it were handpainted complete with brushstrokes etc.?
Thanks
John
-
Your question revolves around what is commonly termed Fair Use and, more specifically, what would appear o be a transformative work... and the answer will depend on which country you live in, as Fair Use laws are not universal.
Absent that specific information, a general guideline would be that the more transformative the work is from the original, the more likely you are to be protected by Fair Use laws in your country.
Using the scenario you postulated, I would personally lean more towards hand painting your interpretation of the movie still via oils on to canvas, as opposed to trying to achieve a similar aesthetic via imaging software.
The skill and effort required to paint by hand points to both originality and a "true" transformation, whereas it might be argued that using image processing software requires less skill and thus be less transformative (the "anyone can do that" statement)
-
Thanks for your reply DVG. Pretty much what I was thinking.
Regards
John