I just received my MasterFile letter today with $16,080.00 demand letter for what they claim is 4 separate pictures that appeared on our website. I had someone do the site years ago I believe they were out of Canada and I have no way of tracking them down. I have contacted 3 people just so try to get help removing the picture. As of yet I can’t even figure that out. On our site it is a single picture but they claim it is 4 of their pictures so I am not sure how that argument plays out. Besides trying to get the picture removed, what direction should I take next? I have no idea where the website company got the image/images that were merged into one. I can't prove they got them legitimately or not. How do I fight the multiple pictures problem even though they had them as one? Do I respond, do I argue the $200 per picture argument and offer to settle?